Bakery Menu & Pricing
Fresh home-baked artisan breads, gourmet cookies, cupcakes, giant cookie cakes, and warm cinnamon rolls handcrafted with love in Appleton, WI.
Fresh From Our Kitchen
Click any photo to explore our gallery. Order directly via Facebook Message or Email for upcoming pickups, parties, and sweet cravings.
Fresh Bread
Fresh home-baked artisan bread loaves, perfect for sandwiches, soups, or sharing.
Cupcakes
Moist, flavorful cupcakes baked fresh for gatherings and sweet cravings.
Cookies
Handcrafted gourmet cookies including chocolate chip, specialty bakes, and mystery Blind Date treats.
Cinnamon Rolls
Soft, golden rolled dough packed with aromatic cinnamon sugar and topped with rich icing.
12-Inch Cookie Cakes
Giant 12-inch freshly baked cookie cakes decorated with piped frosting borders for birthdays, graduations, and celebrations.
Gluten-Friendly Options
We are delighted to offer gluten-friendly cookies, cupcakes, cinnamon rolls, and cookie cakes! All items are home-baked in a shared kitchen that also processes wheat and gluten, designated as gluten-friendly.
Gluten-Friendly S’mores Cookie
Rich chocolate dough infused with gooey marshmallow and graham goodness.
Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Chip Cookie
Classic golden-baked cookie loaded with melty chocolate chips.
Gluten-Friendly Honey Butter Cornbread Cookie
Sweet, soft cornbread cookie drizzled with luscious honey butter glaze.
Gluten-Friendly Cinnamon Roll
Soft swirled cinnamon roll generously smothered in rich sweet icing.
Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Cupcake
Decadent, moist chocolate cupcake crowned with fluffy swirls of frosting.
Ready to Place Your Order?
Reach out directly via Facebook Message or send an email to orders@sugarontheshelfbakery.com with your requested items, quantities, and pickup date!